Thanks to your comments and emails, I have had some great suggestions for lip colors close to my beloved, but unhealthy and discontinued Estee Lauder Divine Wine.
Reader Lavanya suggested a company called Silk Naturals. I was unfamiliar with the line and am so happy she mentioned it. I was thrilled to see that this company is located near Ithaca, just over an hour away from us. The prices are really great, too.
What I like most from what I see, though, is the ingredients! No carmine. No parabens. No nasties....just things like coconut oil, joboba oil, castor oil, etc. I feel good about putting ingredients like that on my lips.
I ordered three lip products in colors I think I will like. Here they are:
Vegan Lipstick in Raisin (Ultra Deep Plum)
Fig Leaf Nude Plum Matte Solid Gloss (not to replace Divine Wine, but as a shade I'd wear daily...)
Vintage Deep Wine Shimmer Liquid Gloss
With shipping, which was a modest charge of only $2.95, I paid $19.39 for 3 lip products. This is less than the cost of my old Divine Wine. When my order arrives and I have tested the lippies out, I will report back!